case study:

Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) Ancestral Territory, Spring Mountains National Recreation Area and Desert National Wildlife Refuge Complex, Nevada, USA.

Photo above: Nuwuvi, U.S. Forest Service, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and The Mountain Institute/Portland State University participants sharing a round dance at the fourth annual Gathering For Our Mountains. September 2014. 

AUTHORS:
Jeremy Spoon
Anthropology Department, Portland State University and The Mountain Institute
Richard Arnold
Pahrump Paiute Tribe

CONTACT:
Jeremy Spoon, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, Anthropology Department, Portland State University
P.O. Box 751, Portland,
Oregon, 97207, USA
jspoon@pdx.edu;
jeremyspoon.com
+1 (503) 725.9729
Summary

Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) consider their ancestral territory alive and imbued with power. They have been the custodians of these lands since the beginning of time. Protected and restricted areas now demarcate large portions of these lands, which span four western U.S. states. The Spring Mountains National Recreation Area (SMNRA) and Desert National Wildlife Refuge Complex (DNWRC) are key landscapes in Nuwuvi creation and contain habitats for numerous culturally and spiritually significant plants, animals, and other natural features. Since 2008, Nuwuvi, SMNRA (U.S. Forest Service) and DNWRC (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service) collaborated on a shared governance framework using working groups of tribally and federally designated representatives to consult on mandated federal policies and mutual interests. This engagement flourished into co-management of shared priorities through special events and projects, including an intergenerational harvest. The partnership also shares information about contemporary indigenous relationships with the land through interpretation. Lessons learned include the importance of rapport building with transparency between indigenous peoples and government agencies and using co-management activities to reunite native peoples with their ancestral territories and reinforce intergenerational knowledge transmission.

Cultural and spiritual significance of nature

Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) view their ancestral homeland as alive and imbued with power. All flora and fauna and natural resources are sentient, interconnected, and have a purpose. Both the Spring Mountains National Recreation Area (SMNRA) and Desert National Wildlife Refuge Complex (DNWRC) are integral to Nuwuvi creation; Nuwuvi consider these landscapes as the center of their universe. At the beginning of time when the world was new, the Creator charged Nuwuvi with balancing the land depending on inferred need or condition. Sustaining balance and preventing land sickness includes creating small-scale disturbances, such as patch burning and clearing springs and water catchment basins, which collectively form a mosaic of relatives or habitats. Kinship is also an integral part of Nuwuvi land management and epistemology; certain families are traditionally designated stewards of particular groves or springs. During mourning rituals, the soul passes through both protected areas as it ceremonially travels along the Salt Song Trail, a journey through song that enables Nuwuvi to transition from this world to another. These locations also contain habitats and locations of numerous culturally and spiritually important resources including caves, springs, rock writing (petroglyphs) sites and endemic plants and animals that keep the world in balance.

Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) ancestral territory, participating protected areas and current reservations.
Project area within the Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) ancestral territory. Area includes the Spring Mountains National Recreation Area and Desert National Wildlfife Refuge Complex. The DNWRC includes four wildlife refuges. Nuvagantu or Nuvankai (Where Snow Sits) or Mount Charleston is the initial Nuwuvi creation point.
Ecology and biodiversity

The SMNRA contains six vegetation zones, creating habitat for several endemic plants and animals. The highest point (3632 m), Nuvankai (Where Snow Sits) or Mount Charleston, is the primary point of Nuwuvi creation. The Spring Mountains are the only range in the southern Great Basin that rises above the timberline. The Desert National Wildlife Refuge Complex, the largest refuge in the contiguous U.S., consists of four refuges with wetland, riparian, and montane ecosystems. DNWRC is habitat for one of the country’s largest desert bighorn sheep herds and desert tortoise and has the country’s greatest concentration of endemic life, including pupfish.

Governance

Both protected areas are under a shared governance framework. The U.S. Forest Service and Fish and Wildlife Service make most decisions; however, since 2010, both agencies implemented a government-to-government consultation framework with Nuwuvi in response to federal laws and topics of mutual interest. This method utilizes specialized working groups of designated experts from seven tribes within the Nuwuvi Nation along with federal agency representatives. Working group members participate in bi-annual meetings and report outcomes back to their respective governments or divisions. The Mountain Institute/Portland State University facilitates the meetings and provides summaries with action items to each participant for approval.

Management

In 2016, Nuwuvi, SMNRA and DNWRC identified pinyon-juniper habitats, hydrology and fire as shared management priorities. Recommendations are implemented through events and projects. For example, at the annual Gathering For Our Mountains intergenerational pine nut harvest and pinyon-juniper stewardship event (since 2012), Nuwuvi families and federal agency volunteers collectively help restore balance to the groves by whipping old cones from trees and clearing out underbrush. These practices assist in minimizing catastrophic crown fire risk and pinyon-juniper habitat expansion. Co-created interpretation at multiple visitor centers, trails and public art pieces also helps communicate these collaborative activities to the public.

Lessons learned

Collaboration among Nuwuvi, federal agencies and The Mountain Institute/Portland State University began in 2008 with the co-creation of interpretive content for multiple visitor centers. The mutual trust established through these projects evolved into a shared governance framework and unique co-management capacity building. Primary lessons learned include:

  • Focusing on shared mutual interests and defining a path forward. This project utilized interpretive planning as a springboard for other projects. Both the government and tribal representatives had special connections with the protected areas and wanted to interpret them for enhanced public protection. The Nuwuvi Working Group co-conducted ethnographic research with their elders to determine what information to share for building design, exhibits and public art at four locations.
  • Building rapport coupled with leveraging existing laws and policies. In the U.S., compliance with federal policies, such as the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA), American Indian Religious Freedom Act (AIRFA), National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA), and Executive Order 13007 (recognition and access to sacred sites), were used to sustain relationships between indigenous peoples and government agencies.
  • Making transparency vital to success. Participants had the ability to address and overcome challenging issues through candid conversations, trust and exposure to different perspectives. Rapport building with transparency was also a key component in managing expectations.
  • Ensuring leadership participation. Decision-makers from both federal agencies and tribes participated in bi-annual meetings and other rapport building activities, such as the annual and collaborative Gathering For Our Mountains.
  • Maintaining institutional memory. A framework of regular activities (meetings, events, etc.) built a foundation to engage and train new staff without losing momentum.
  • Providing interactive opportunities. Intergenerational and cross-cultural knowledge exchange occurred at meeting and events, which reinforced partnerships.
  • Co-creating interpretation. Tribal representatives guided interpretative information for the public about the cultural significance of these important places within a broader indigenous homeland.
Barcalow, Kate. 2015. Contested Landscapes: An Analysis of Using the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) for Traditional Cultural Properties (TCPs) in the Western United States. Master’s Thesis, Anthropology Department, Portland State University, Portland, OR.
Euler, Robert C. 1966. Southern Paiute Ethnohistory. Reno, Nevada: University of Utah Press.
Fowler, Catherine S. 1986. Subsistence. In Handbook of North American Indians: Great Basin, Vol. 11. W.L. D’Azevedo, ed. Washington D.C.: Smithsonian Institute. Pp. 64-79.
Fowler, Catherine S. 1995. Some Notes on Ethnographic Subsistence Systems in Mojavean Environments in the Great Basin. Journal of Ethnobiology 15(1):99-117.
Fowler, Don. D., and Catherine S. Fowler. 1971 (eds). Anthropology of the Numa; John Wesley Powell’s Manuscripts on the Numic Peoples of Western North America, 1868-1889. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington D.C.
Fowler, Don. D., and Catherine. S. Fowler (eds). 2008. The Great Basin: People and Places in Ancient Times. School for Advanced Research Press, Santa Fe, NM.
Grayson, Don. K. 2008. The Great Basin: A Natural Prehistory. University of California Press, Berkeley.
Holt, Richard. L. 2006. Beneath These Red Cliffs: An Ethnohistory of the Utah Paiutes. Logan, Utah: Utah State University Press.
Kelly, Isabel T. & Catherine S. Fowler. 1986. Southern Paiute. In Handbook of North Americas: Great Basin. Vol. 11. W.L. D’Azevedo, ed. Washington D.C.: Smithsonian Institute. Pp. 370-371.
Knack, M. 2001. Boundaries Between: The Southern Paiutes, 1775-1995. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln.
Lahoff, Rachel. 2014. The Search for Interpretation Sovereignty: Accommodating Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) Voice in Protected Area Interpretation. Master’s Thesis, Anthropology Department, Portland State University, Portland, OR.
Laird, Carolbeth. and George. Laird. 1976. The Chemehuevis. Banning, California: Malki Museum Press.
Lefler, Brian. J. 2014. Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) Ecological Knowledge of Piñon-Juniper Woodlands: Implications for Conservation and Sustainable Resource Use in Two Southern Nevada Protected Areas. Master’s Thesis, Anthropology Department, Portland State University, Portland, OR.
Rhode, David. 2002. Native Plants of Southern Nevada: An Ethnobotany. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
Sapir, Edward. 1992. The Collected Works of Edward Sapir: Southern Paiute and Ute Linguistics and Ethnography. Bright, William, ed. New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Spoon, Jeremy. 2013. Different Ways of Knowing, Shared Goals: Applied Sustainability Projects in the Himalayas and Great Basin. In J. Dillard, V. Dujon and E. Brennan eds. Social Sustainability: A Multilevel Approach to Social Inclusion. London: Routledge. Pp. 211-232.
Spoon, Jeremy. 2014. Quantitative, Qualitative and Collaborative Methods: Approaching Indigenous Ecology Knowledge Heterogeneity. Ecology and Society 19(3).
Spoon, Jeremy and Richard Arnold. 2012. Collaborative Research and Co-Learning: Integrating Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) Ecological Knowledge and Spirituality to Revitalize a Fragmented Land. Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature and Culture 6(4): 477-500.
Spoon, Jeremy, Richard Arnold, Brian Lefler and Christopher Milton. 2015. Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute), Shifting Fire Regimes, and the Carpenter One Fire in the Spring Mountains National Recreation Area, Nevada. Journal of Ethnobiology 35(1): 85-110.
Spoon, Jeremy, Richard Arnold, and The Nuwuvi Working Group. 2011. Nuwu Kanee, Nuwu Tooveenup (Our Home, Our Story): Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) and the Spring Mountains. Portland, Oregon: The Mountain Institute and Portland State University.
Spoon, Jeremy, Richard Arnold, and The Nuwuvi Working Group. 2012a.Nuwu-Vots (Our Footprints): Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) and the Pahranagat Valley. Portland, Oregon: The Mountain Institute and Portland State University.
Spoon, Jeremy, Richard Arnold, and The Nuwuvi Working Group. 2012b. Our Gathering Place: Newe (Western Shoshone), Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) and the Ash Meadows Landscape. Portland, Oregon: The Mountain Institute and Portland State University.
Spoon, Jeremy, Richard Arnold and the Nuwuvi Working Group. 2014. The Voices of the Rocks Sing Through Us: Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) and Black Canyon. Portland, Oregon: The Mountain Institute and Portland State University.
Spoon, Jeremy, Richard Arnold, Karla Hambelton, and the Nuwuvi Working Group. 2012. Consultation Handbook: Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute), the Spring Mountains National Recreation Area and the Desert National Wildlife Refuge Complex. Portland, Oregon: The Mountain Institute and Portland State University.
Spoon, Jeremy, Richard Arnold, Brian Lefler, Kendra Wendel, the Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) Working Group, the U.S. Forest Service, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2013. Collaborative Resource Stewardship Plan: Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute), the Spring Mountains National Recreation Area and the Desert National Wildlife Refuge Complex. Portland, Oregon: The Mountain Institute and Portland State University.
Steward, Julian H. 1997 [1938]. Basin-Plateau Aboriginal Sociopolitical Groups. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
Steward, Julian H. 1955. Theory of Culture Change: The Methodology of Multilinear Evolution. University of Illinois Press, Urbana, IL.
Stoffle, Richard W., David B. Halmo, Johan E. Omsted, and Michael J. Evans. 1990. Native American Cultural Resources Studies at Yucca Mountain, Nevada. Ann Arbor, Michigan: The Institute for Social Research, The University of Michigan.
Stoffle, Richard W., David B. Halmo and Diane E. Austin. 1997. Cultural Landscapes and Traditional Cultural Properties: A Southern Paiute View of the Grand Canyon. American Indian Quarterly 21(2).
Stoffle, Richard W., David B. Halmo and Michael J. Evans. 1999. Puchuxwavaats Uapi (To Know About Plants): Traditional Knowledge and Cultural Significance of Southern Paiute Plants. Human Organization 58(4): 416-429.
Stoffle, Richard W. Stoffle, María Nieves Zedeño, and David L. Halmo. 2001. American Indians and the Nevada Test Site: A Model of Research and Consultation. Washington D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Survant, Cerinda. 2016. (Re)Presenting Stories on Living Lands: Public Presentation of Archaeology and Representation of Native Americans in Western U.S. Protected Areas. Master’s Thesis, Anthropology Department, Portland State University, Portland, OR.
Wendel, Kendra. 2014. Lifeblood of the Earth: Nuwuvi (Southern Paiute) Hydrological Knowledge and Perceptions of Restoration in Two Southern Nevada Protected Areas. Master’s Thesis, Anthropology Department, Portland State University, Portland, OR.
error: